NIBA - Celebrating 35 Years
Back to Journal
MF Global Updates

Judges in MF Global and PFG Bankruptcies to Decide Whether Proprietary FCM Assets are Allocated to Make Up Customer Seg Shortfalls

N
Written by
NIBA
Published
Reading time
2 min

The recent failures of MF Global and PFG represent two devastating FCM bankruptcies with substantial shortfalls in customer segregated assets. Each company also has significant firm assets – the MF Global trustee has apparently recovered more than $1.2B of firm assets and while it is too early to know what the PFG trustee will be able to marshal, PFG reported $31M of regulatory capital in its most recent Form 1-FR-FCM filing and there are news reports of an $18M office building, a $7M+ private jet and an array of other businesses and smaller properties.

CFTC regulations provide that if there is a shortfall in customer segregated assets then FCM firm assets should be reallocated to make up the shortfall, giving priority to commodity customers over creditor claims. However, a bankruptcy court has found this rule to be invalid as exceeding the CFTC rule-making authority. The MF Global trustee and the CFTC have voiced their views that the regulation should be upheld, while it is too early for the PFG trustee to have expressed his opinion. Judges in both cases will likely need to decide whether to uphold the regulation, which would provide significant additional recoveries and priority for commodity customers.

Neal R. Stevens
Of Counsel
nstevens@SRCattorneys.com
312 565.1045 tel (chi) |  212 334.7948 tel (nyc)

Schuyler, Roche & Crisham, P.C
www.SRCattorneys.com

 

The Opinions expressed are the opinions of the author. The opinions, the trading styles, trading information and trading programs are not endorsed by the NIBA, but are the individual opinions, styles, information and programs of the author.

Stay Informed

Subscribe to the NIBA Journal for the latest insights and industry updates

Related Articles

View All
MF Global Updates

MF Global customers to be fully reimbursed, trustee says

Today marks the beginning of a $6.7 billion payout to the former customers of MF Global Holdings. The process is expected to take several weeks but will return all the money that is owed to the approximately 26,500 former commodities and securities customers of the failed brokerage. "Checks are going in the mail that will make all public customers of MF Global Inc. 100% whole," trustee James Giddens said in a statement. Read Full Article at FIA SmartBrief

MF Global Updates

Request for Comments – CPO/CTA Capital Requirement and Customer Protection Measures-Comments Due by April 15, 2014

NFA regularly reviews the continued effectiveness of its regulatory requirements. Over the past three years, NFA has issued 26 Member Responsibility Actions (MRAs), and 92% of those MRAs were against CPO and/or CTA Members. Most of these matters involved misuse of customer funds (including one CPO that improperly used pool funds because it had insufficient assets to operate as a going concern) and/or misstating net asset values and/or performance information. In light of these actions, NFA is reviewing the current regulatory structure applicable to CPO and CTA operations. In particular, NFA is looking at ways to strengthen the regulatory structure governing CPO operations to provide greater protection for customer funds. Additionally, NFA is exploring ways to ensure that CPOs and...

MF Global Updates

Peregrine Financial Trustee Seeks to Return $41 Mln to Clients

Peregrine Financial Group's bankruptcy trustee plans to return up to $41 million to former customers of the failed futures brokerage in the second payout since the firm collapsed 17 months ago. Court-appointed trustee Ira Bodenstein is seeking to return about 7 percent, or $27.5 million, to Peregrine customers who traded on U.S. exchanges, according to court filings. In the first payout last year, the group, which comprised the bulk of the firm's clients, received back about 30 percent of the money they had in accounts when Peregrine failed. Clients who traded on foreign markets would get back about 45 percent more of their money, or $13.5 million, in the second payout, court documents show. They received back about 40 percent...